HISTORY August 8, 2025 7 min read

THE HOWL CONTROVERSY STORY

The fascinating story behind how M4A4 Howl became contraband and why it's one of the most expensive skins in CS:GO history.

M4A4 Howl

The M4A4 Howl holds a unique position in CS:GO history as the only weapon skin to achieve "Contraband" status. This designation wasn't planned by Valve - it was the result of a copyright controversy that transformed an already popular skin into one of the game's most valuable and sought-after items.

The Original Design

Originally submitted to the Steam Workshop by artist "Apel" in collaboration with "sic", the Howl featured a striking design centered around a snarling wolf's head. The artwork was bold, aggressive, and perfectly suited to the M4A4's militaristic aesthetic. The community embraced the design, and it was officially added to the game as part of the Huntsman Weapon Case on May 1, 2014.

The Copyright Crisis

Shortly after release, it was discovered that the wolf artwork was allegedly based on copyrighted material without proper permission. The original artist whose work had been used filed a DMCA complaint with Valve, claiming their artwork had been plagiarized and used without authorization in the Howl design.

Valve's Response

Faced with a legitimate copyright claim, Valve took unprecedented action. Rather than simply removing the skin from the game - which would have caused chaos for existing owners - they created an entirely new rarity tier: "Contraband." All existing Howl skins were reclassified with this special status, and the original artwork was replaced with a new design featuring different wolf imagery to avoid further copyright issues.

Market Impact

The contraband designation had an immediate and dramatic effect on the Howl's market value. Since no new Howl skins could be obtained from cases, the existing supply became finite. Combined with the skin's already strong popularity and its unique story, prices began climbing rapidly. What once sold for $50-100 suddenly commanded hundreds, then thousands of dollars.

Current Market Values

  • Factory New: $8,000 - $12,000+
  • Minimal Wear: $4,000 - $6,000
  • Field-Tested: $2,500 - $3,500
  • Well-Worn: $2,000 - $2,800
  • Battle-Scarred: $1,800 - $2,400

The Sticker Connection

The Howling Dawn sticker, which was also part of the same controversy, was similarly removed from cases and given contraband status. This sticker, featuring the same wolf design as the original Howl, has become incredibly valuable in its own right, often selling for thousands of dollars and adding significant premium when applied to weapons.

Investment Perspective

From an investment standpoint, the Howl represents a unique case study in artificial scarcity within gaming economies. The finite supply, combined with CS:GO's growing player base and the skin's legendary status, has created consistent upward price pressure. Low-float Factory New examples are particularly sought after by collectors.

Legacy

The Howl controversy established important precedents for intellectual property in gaming and demonstrated Valve's commitment to respecting artists' rights. Today, the M4A4 Howl stands as both a valuable collectible and a piece of gaming history, representing a unique moment when legal issues transformed a weapon skin into a legend. Its contraband status ensures it will forever remain one of the most exclusive and valuable items in CS:GO.

Related Products

M4A4 Howl

M4A4 | HOWL

$2,899.99

M4A4 Neo-Noir

M4A4 | NEO-NOIR

$67.99

M4A1-S Hyper Beast

M4A1-S | HYPER BEAST

$34.99